Fusaro`s in Nantucket

Great family owned restaurant with enthusiastic staff and thoughtful cuisine

Waitress was great. Appetizers arrived on time. Main courses were woefully delayed!!! Obviously, take-out orders were given priority over our in-restaurant order. If you risk going here, before you sit down, make sure management agrees to prioritize your in-restaurant order over take-out orders.

Good pasta dish. Chewy bread. Deemed microwabed to warn.Rather slow service. Air conditioner blowing freezing cold air on diners and food. Seems like a neighborhood-like place with regular diners enjoying each other's company. Pizza looked great at the next table. May try that and bring a sweater.

Food good service ok

Went to Fusaro's 3 times during my visit to the Island last week. Sat at the bar all 3 times and the bartender, Melissa, is a gem! Absolutely the best and friendliest person and the drinks were great, Linguine and clams was awesome and the desserts were to die for! Had lots of fun hanging with some of the locals too.

The staff is really friendly and food is good

Enjoy this place, delicious food, service was great.

Great meal... Awesome ambience!!

On a July Sunday night we had excellent food and service! Spicy calamari, Nona's meatballs and 2 pasta dishes...all great. The bar was quick to supply our wine and gin and tonics. Great atmosphere with the regulars at the bar later in the evening. Definitely recommend!

Good food, but Very expensive for a pasta restaurant.

Very much improved. House made pasta and much more.

From the hostess to the bartender to the server to the chef.. this place is lights out. This is going to be our first stop once we get back here. Hats off to Fusaros.. you guys knocked it out of the park. Thank you so much for everything!

Food was excellent , price was very good. Would have liked to have had some bread with dinner, but our waitress seemed preoccupied. I did mention it, got a smile and she moved on. Everything else was great and I would definitely recommend the restaurant. The veal dish was delicious.

Great pizza and awesome staff

Why don’t you try to better manage quantity? I didn’t think chickens were that small to provide so few pieces on my salad

Great service and awesome food. Had the Nantucket Scallops, Fettuccini Alfredo with chicken, Linguini and Clams, Scallop Chowder, and Eggplant Parmesan

Never has a bad meal. Ambiance is mediocre. 2ND best Italian on the island.

Food was very good, quick and perfect temperature. Only upset is I wish I had tried here before...

Great service. Food was ok

Got takeout. Very expensive, small portion, very basic Italian. If not on Nantucket they would not survive!

Great food and service

Fusaro's is a fantastic Italian restaurant on Nantucket island. The food is phenomenal and the service is top tier. This is one of the better restaurants on Nantucket that no one is talking about. For anyone visiting the island looking for a great place for dinner away from the crowds on Main Street Fusaro's is your place. I highly recommend this restaurant.

Wonderful meal super nice hostess and waitress.

I’ve never been inside, review based solely off the Alfredo- take out. Absolutely PHENOMENAL! Perfect every time.

Absolutely the worst. It took me 15 minutes to get them on the phone, not the biggest deal. We got two pizzas and two pasta dishes. Smallest portions I've ever seen and twice the price. I ordered a margarita pizza which is the most simple thing to make. It's fresh mozzarella, tomatoes and fresh basil on pizza crust. There was no mozzarella no sliced tomatoes and I wouldn't call the basil fresh by any means. Don't waste your time or money. Worst way to end a vacation.

It's a good restaurant I will definitely go again if I'm on Nantucket my favorite restaurant for Italian on Nantucket

Ordered to go chicken parm tonight. Told me8 pm pick up. They came outside promptly at 8 to deliver my food! I went home and enjoyed a delicious meal!! Sooo good! Even gave me some bread per my request. I will be back! Top notch establishment!

Wonderful food and service

Soooo good! Great food and atmosphere!

Waiter was amazing, Had us all laughing. Drinks were great and always great food

No flavor. Had the fusile genovese. It was take out. No cheese in the order, small portions, chicken Limone, one small piece of chicken in the order. Dussaoointing.

As always, excellent food & excellent hospitality!!

Entrées are priced lower than average in the $15 range. Kind of like an independent Olive Garden. Food was better than Olive Garden, though. Good if you're cost-conscious.

Great food good service

I ordered a salad plus shrimp for $20. The salad was so small I thought I had accidentally ordered from the appetizer menu. There were 4 shrimp (so $2 per shrimp) which is sometimes typical in a restaurant but never have I seen a restaurant scrimp on the salad portion so much. For the first time in my life I left a restaurant hungry, even after my husband was kind enough to give me a bite of his chicken and we both ordered desserts. I could have ordered a second meal I guess, but for $20 I thought I'd be getting a real meal. And I am normally the person taking half of my food home. Everything did taste good at least. Now every time a restaurant serves us way too much food, we joke that it least it isn't the Nantucket salad snack on the other side of the spectrum.

Always friendly service...great food

Great place for dinner

Pizza was okay, took a while to get because they can only make one every 15 minuets. In the future I would call ahead to place my to go order.

Best pizza I've had on the island! Great atmosphere!

Loved the service and how friendly they were. Attentive to our needs and awesome to kids!!!

Always consistent and good,great pizza,best prices

Great for pizza, and eat-in dining. I was very disappointed when I ordered this dish to-go for $22 +tax. No bread, no side salad, not even a fork and knife. This was ordered back in February 2020

We visited this restaurant with fairly high hopes until the food came. It was actually not bad; the pizza was well made and featured fresh ingredients. My main gripe with the restaurant was that half of our food didn't arrive until the other half was nearly gone, so we had a table half full of people eating and half sitting awkwardly waiting. Our waitress was not interested in checking on the order for us, simply reminding us that it was on its way every now and then, and the management was quite frankly uninterested in hearing about or apologizing for the terrible service. I honestly can't recommend a restaurant whose management cares so little!

Very good Italian food. The wait staff is very friendly and service is quick. The menu changes occasionally so there's always something new to try. Even tho the place is small parking can be a bit tricky during the busiest hours. Definitely try the olive oil on the bread.

Casual and comfortable with a cozy little bar. Food's good!

Loved the pasta and meats

I always make sure I eat here when visiting. Outside seating is cozy and the service is always great. Oh, and the food is awesome!

Very family friendly

Food is the real deal. Waiters really know there stuff. Excellent

I lived the food, but for the prices some of the dishes can be small.